Hampshire College vs Macalester College

Frequently Asked Questions

• What are the core academic philosophies of Hampshire College and Macalester College?

  Hampshire College emphasizes self-directed learning and interdisciplinary studies. Students design their own academic concentrations (Divisions) and complete independent projects. Macalester College, while also valuing interdisciplinary approaches, offers a more structured liberal arts curriculum with established majors and minors. Macalester encourages global citizenship and social justice through its curriculum and co-curricular activities, while Hampshire focuses on individualized learning paths.

• How do the campus environments and locations differ between Hampshire and Macalester?

  Hampshire College is located in Amherst, Massachusetts, as part of the Five College Consortium, offering access to resources and courses at Amherst, Mount Holyoke, Smith, and UMass Amherst. This provides a more rural, collaborative academic environment. Macalester College is situated in a residential neighborhood of Saint Paul, Minnesota, providing a more urban experience with access to the Twin Cities' cultural and professional opportunities. Macalester's campus is self-contained, fostering a strong sense of community within the college itself.

• What are the typical class sizes and student-faculty ratios at Hampshire and Macalester?

  Hampshire College generally has very small class sizes, often fewer than 15 students, and a low student-faculty ratio, fostering close interaction between students and professors. Macalester College also boasts small class sizes, typically around 18-20 students, and a favorable student-faculty ratio, allowing for personalized attention and mentorship. Both colleges prioritize a close-knit learning environment.

• How do Hampshire and Macalester approach grading and assessment?

  Hampshire College uses a narrative evaluation system instead of traditional letter grades. Faculty provide detailed written evaluations of student work, focusing on progress and learning outcomes. Macalester College uses a traditional grading system (A-F) but also emphasizes feedback and opportunities for improvement. While both value student growth, Hampshire's approach is more qualitative and Macalester's is more quantitative.

• What types of students thrive at Hampshire College versus Macalester College?

  Hampshire College is well-suited for highly motivated, independent learners who are comfortable designing their own curriculum and taking initiative in their education. Students who thrive at Hampshire are often creative, unconventional, and passionate about pursuing unique academic interests. Macalester College is a good fit for students who seek a strong liberal arts education with a global focus and a commitment to social justice. Students who thrive at Macalester are often intellectually curious, engaged in their communities, and interested in making a positive impact on the world.

• What are the strengths of Hampshire College's Five College Consortium affiliation?

  Hampshire College's membership in the Five College Consortium provides students with access to a vast array of courses, resources, and social activities across five distinct institutions. This allows Hampshire students to broaden their academic horizons, participate in diverse extracurriculars, and connect with a larger community of students and faculty. The consortium expands the resources available to Hampshire students far beyond what a small, independent college could offer alone.

• How do the career services and alumni networks compare between Hampshire and Macalester?

  Both Hampshire and Macalester offer career services to help students with internships, job searches, and career planning. Macalester's location in the Twin Cities provides access to a wider range of internship and job opportunities in various industries. Macalester also has a strong and active alumni network that supports current students and graduates. Hampshire's alumni network, while smaller, is known for its entrepreneurial spirit and commitment to social change. Both colleges are dedicated to helping their students succeed after graduation.

• What is the general atmosphere and campus culture like at each college?

  Hampshire College has a reputation for being a progressive and experimental community with a strong emphasis on creativity, social justice, and individual expression. The campus culture is known for being open-minded, collaborative, and student-driven. Macalester College also fosters a progressive and inclusive environment with a focus on global citizenship, social responsibility, and intellectual curiosity. The campus culture is known for being academically rigorous, politically engaged, and internationally diverse.

• How do the costs of attendance and financial aid opportunities compare between Hampshire and Macalester?

  The cost of attendance at both Hampshire and Macalester is relatively high, as is typical of private liberal arts colleges. Both institutions offer financial aid packages to students based on need, including grants, scholarships, and loans. It's important to compare the specific financial aid offers from each college to determine which is more affordable for your individual circumstances. Contact the financial aid offices at both colleges for personalized estimates.

• What are some notable academic programs or areas of strength at each college?

  Hampshire College is known for its strengths in interdisciplinary studies, media arts and sciences, cognitive science, and social justice. Its open curriculum allows students to create unique programs tailored to their interests. Macalester College is recognized for its programs in international studies, political science, economics, and environmental studies. It also has a strong emphasis on languages and area studies, reflecting its global focus.