Carthage College vs Carroll University

Carthage College and Carroll University, both esteemed institutions of higher learning in Wisconsin, offer distinct educational experiences. Carthage, a private liberal arts college, boasts a 70% acceptance rate, while Carroll, a private comprehensive university, has a slightly higher acceptance rate of 75%. Carthage's student body is predominantly female (60%), while Carroll's is more evenly balanced (52% female, 48% male). Both institutions offer a diverse range of undergraduate programs, with popular majors at Carthage including Business, Education, and Psychology, and popular majors at Carroll including Business, Nursing, and Biology. With graduation rates of 68% and 65% respectively, both Carthage and Carroll are committed to student success. Explore the detailed comparison table below to discover more about these two exceptional institutions and determine which one aligns best with your academic aspirations and personal preferences.
Carroll University logo

Carroll University

Carthage College logo

Carthage College

Overview

Location Waukesha, Wisconsin Kenosha, Wisconsin
Campus setting City: Small Suburb: Midsize
College type 4 year 4 year
Control/business model Private (Non Profit) Private (Non Profit)
Calendar system Semester 4-1-4
Degrees offered Undergraduate and Graduate Undergraduate and Graduate
Students retention rate 78.0% 73.0%
Common app member Yes Yes
Religious affiliation Presbyterian Evangelical

Admission

Acceptance rate 70.5% 75.7%
Application fees
Undergraduate: $35

Graduate: $35
SAT range 1070 - 1290 980 - 1200
ACT range 22 - 27 20 - 27
Students submitting SAT score 5.0% 20.0%
Students submitting ACT score 40.0% 39.0%
Total number of applicants 4,481 8,639
Total number of admissions given out 3,159 6,539
Admitted students who chose to enroll 678 763
Yield rate 21.5% 11.7%
Test scores (SAT/ACT) N/A N/A
High school GPA Required Required
Recommendation letters Not required Not required
High school transcript Not required Not required
English proficiency test (e.g. TOEFL) Required Not required

Tuition and Fees

Sticker price $48,498 $49,000
Average net price $24,050 $26,643
Tuition $34,330 $33,000
Room & board $11,690 $12,400
Available payment plans
  • Tuition payment plan
  • Tuition payment plan

Financial Aid

Students receiving financial aid

(Grants & scholarships)

100.0%
Average amount $22,168
98.0%
Average amount $18,544
Students receiving federal student loan 67.0%
Average amount $5,210
71.0%
Average amount $5,205
Students taking out private loans 13.0%
Average amount $14,318
16.0%
Average amount $15,990

Students and Campus

Undergraduate students 2,884
Men 30.5% Women 69.5%
2,635
Men 43.8% Women 56.2%
Graduate students 513
Men 34.5% Women 65.5%
111
Men 41.4% Women 58.6%
Racial/ethnic diversity
Very Low
Low
Out-of-state students 29.3% N/A
International students 1.4% 1.4%
Campus local/setting City: Small Suburb: Midsize
Dormitory capacity 1,795 1,817
First year students are required to live on campus? No No
Top 5 states where most U.S. students come from Wisconsin Illinois Minnesota Puerto Rico Florida N/A

Academics

Popular study areas
  • Health Professions
  • Education
  • Kinesiology & Leisure Studies
  • Business
  • Biological and Biomedical Sciences
  • Education
  • Health Professions
  • Business
  • Kinesiology & Leisure Studies
  • Visual & Performing Arts
Students to faculty ratio 14:1 13:1
Institutional accreditation Higher Learning Commission Higher Learning Commission

Outcome

Graduation rate 67.4% 68.0%
Dropout rate 32.2% 32.0%
Transferred out N/A N/A
Alumni salary by major (Top 10)
Allied Health Diagnostic, Intervention, and Treatment Professions (Master's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $102,050
  • Year 2: $108,426
  • Year 3: $104,032
Health Services/Allied Health/Health Sciences, General (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $65,660
  • Year 2: $74,576
  • Year 3: $76,900
Business Administration, Management and Operations (Master's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $70,607
  • Year 2: $65,797
  • Year 3: $73,583
Rehabilitation and Therapeutic Professions (First Professional Degrees)
  • Year 1: $69,728
  • Year 2: $71,326
  • Year 3: $72,017
Registered Nursing, Nursing Administration, Nursing Research and Clinical Nursing (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $62,920
  • Year 2: $61,317
  • Year 3: $64,501
Accounting and Related Services (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $55,293
  • Year 2: $54,644
  • Year 3: $61,206
Health and Physical Education/Fitness (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: N/A
  • Year 2: $32,925
  • Year 3: $60,076
Business Administration, Management and Operations (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $39,954
  • Year 2: $45,618
  • Year 3: $53,524
Teacher Education and Professional Development, Specific Levels and Methods (Master's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $53,102
  • Year 2: $51,273
  • Year 3: $52,580
Biology, General (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $36,528
  • Year 2: $36,992
  • Year 3: $49,981
Finance and Financial Management Services (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $51,296
  • Year 2: $53,537
  • Year 3: $65,252
Accounting and Related Services (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $56,636
  • Year 2: $52,524
  • Year 3: $60,729
Business Administration, Management and Operations (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $46,987
  • Year 2: $49,615
  • Year 3: $58,626
Public Relations, Advertising, and Applied Communication (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $42,342
  • Year 2: $43,798
  • Year 3: $57,509
Marketing (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $43,583
  • Year 2: $46,357
  • Year 3: $54,282
Mathematics (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $33,792
  • Year 2: $37,856
  • Year 3: $53,964
Biology, General (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $24,906
  • Year 2: $33,565
  • Year 3: $46,473
Design and Applied Arts (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $35,624
  • Year 2: $41,193
  • Year 3: $45,143
Health and Physical Education/Fitness (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $27,848
  • Year 2: $35,060
  • Year 3: $43,954
Communication and Media Studies (Bachelor's Degrees)
  • Year 1: $36,255
  • Year 2: $32,563
  • Year 3: $41,675

Frequently Asked Questions


  • What are the primary differences between Carthage College and Carroll University?

    Carthage College is a private, four-year liberal arts college affiliated with the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, known for its strong focus on undergraduate education and a close-knit campus community. Carroll University, also private, has a broader range of programs, including graduate studies, and a slightly larger student body. Carroll is historically affiliated with the Presbyterian Church. Carthage emphasizes experiential learning and undergraduate research, while Carroll offers a wider array of professional programs alongside its liberal arts offerings.

  • How do the campus environments compare at Carthage and Carroll?

    Carthage College boasts a beautiful lakeside campus on the shores of Lake Michigan, providing stunning views and a serene atmosphere. Carroll University is located in Waukesha, Wisconsin, a suburban setting that offers a blend of campus life and access to city amenities. Carthage's smaller size fosters a more intimate and residential campus experience, while Carroll's location provides greater access to internships and off-campus activities in the Waukesha and Milwaukee areas.

  • What academic programs are particularly strong at each institution?

    Carthage College is recognized for its strong programs in natural sciences (particularly biology and chemistry), business, communication, and performing arts. They also have a distinctive space science program. Carroll University excels in health sciences (nursing, physical therapy, occupational therapy), business, education, and pre-professional programs. Carroll's graduate programs in health-related fields are a significant strength.

  • How do the costs of attending Carthage College and Carroll University compare?

    Both Carthage College and Carroll University are private institutions, and their tuition costs are generally comparable. However, the actual cost of attendance can vary significantly based on individual financial aid packages, scholarships, and grants. It's essential to compare the net cost (tuition minus financial aid) at each institution based on your specific financial situation. Contact the financial aid offices at both colleges for personalized estimates.

  • What is the student-faculty ratio at Carthage and Carroll, and how does this impact the learning environment?

    Carthage College typically has a student-faculty ratio around 12:1, while Carroll University's is around 13:1. These relatively low ratios indicate that students at both institutions can expect smaller class sizes and more personalized attention from professors. This fosters a more interactive and engaging learning environment, allowing for closer relationships with faculty and greater opportunities for mentorship and research collaboration.

  • What types of extracurricular activities and student organizations are available at each college?

    Both Carthage College and Carroll University offer a wide range of extracurricular activities, including student government, clubs, organizations, performing arts groups, and intramural sports. Carthage has a strong emphasis on Greek life and a vibrant campus activities board. Carroll University offers a diverse range of clubs and organizations catering to academic, cultural, and recreational interests, with a strong focus on service learning and community engagement.

  • What are the athletic programs like at Carthage College and Carroll University?

    Carthage College is a member of the NCAA Division III College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin (CCIW) and offers a comprehensive athletic program with a strong tradition of success. Carroll University is also a member of the CCIW and offers a similar range of NCAA Division III sports. Both institutions provide opportunities for student-athletes to compete at a high level while maintaining a focus on academics.

  • How do Carthage and Carroll support career development and job placement for their graduates?

    Both Carthage College and Carroll University have dedicated career services offices that provide students with resources and support for career exploration, resume writing, interview preparation, and job searching. Carthage emphasizes internships and experiential learning opportunities to prepare students for the workforce. Carroll University leverages its location in Waukesha and proximity to Milwaukee to connect students with internships and job opportunities in various industries, particularly in healthcare and business.

  • What are the religious affiliations of Carthage College and Carroll University, and how does this impact campus life?

    Carthage College is affiliated with the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA), while Carroll University is historically affiliated with the Presbyterian Church (USA). While both institutions maintain their religious affiliations, they are open to students of all faiths and backgrounds. The religious affiliations may be reflected in campus ministry programs, service opportunities, and values-based leadership initiatives, but they do not typically dominate the overall campus culture.

  • What are the typical class sizes at Carthage College and Carroll University?

    Both Carthage College and Carroll University pride themselves on offering smaller class sizes, which allows for more personalized attention from professors. At Carthage, the average class size is around 18 students. Carroll University's average class size is similar, typically ranging from 18-22 students. This intimate learning environment fosters greater interaction between students and faculty.

Compare Similar Colleges

The list of suggested college comparisons provided below is generated automatically by our system, utilizing statistics gathered from the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) and various online sources. If you don't find the colleges you wish to compare, please visit our comparison page. There, you can search for the specific colleges and initiate your comparison.
Carroll University Carroll University vs McKendree University McKendree University
Carroll University Carroll University vs Rockford University Rockford University
Carroll University Carroll University vs St. John's College-Department of Nursing St. John's College-Department of Nursing
Carroll University Carroll University vs Clarke University Clarke University
Carroll University Carroll University vs Andrews University Andrews University
Carroll University Carroll University vs Aquinas College Aquinas College
Carroll University Carroll University vs Fontbonne University Fontbonne University
Carroll University Carroll University vs Carroll College Carroll College
Carroll University Carroll University vs Nebraska Wesleyan University Nebraska Wesleyan University
Carroll University Carroll University vs Alverno College Alverno College
Carroll University Carroll University vs Cardinal Stritch University Cardinal Stritch University
Carroll University Carroll University vs Lawrence University Lawrence University
Carroll University Carroll University vs Maranatha Baptist University Maranatha Baptist University
Carroll University Carroll University vs Milwaukee School of Engineering Milwaukee School of Engineering
Carroll University Carroll University vs Mount Mary University Mount Mary University
Carroll University Carroll University vs Northland College Northland College
Carroll University Carroll University vs Ripon College Ripon College
Carroll University Carroll University vs University of Wisconsin-Stout University of Wisconsin-Stout
Carroll University Carroll University vs University of Wisconsin-Superior University of Wisconsin-Superior
Carroll University Carroll University vs University of Wisconsin-Platteville University of Wisconsin-Platteville
Carroll University Carroll University vs University of Wisconsin-River Falls University of Wisconsin-River Falls
Carroll University Carroll University vs University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point
Carthage College Carthage College vs Hendrix College Hendrix College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Flagler College Flagler College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Augustana College Augustana College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Aurora University Aurora University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Bradley University Bradley University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Elmhurst University Elmhurst University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Illinois Wesleyan University Illinois Wesleyan University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Knox College Knox College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Lewis University Lewis University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Loyola University Chicago Loyola University Chicago
Carthage College Carthage College vs Millikin University Millikin University
Carthage College Carthage College vs North Central College North Central College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Olivet Nazarene University Olivet Nazarene University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Rockford University Rockford University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Roosevelt University Roosevelt University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Saint Xavier University Saint Xavier University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Wheaton College Wheaton College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Loras College Loras College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Luther College Luther College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Wartburg College Wartburg College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Bethany College Bethany College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Albion College Albion College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Aquinas College Aquinas College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Central Michigan University Central Michigan University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Eastern Michigan University Eastern Michigan University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Grand Valley State University Grand Valley State University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Hope College Hope College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Michigan State University Michigan State University
Carthage College Carthage College vs The College of Saint Scholastica The College of Saint Scholastica
Carthage College Carthage College vs Carroll College Carroll College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Siena College Siena College
Carthage College Carthage College vs SUNY College of Agriculture and Technology at Cobleskill SUNY College of Agriculture and Technology at Cobleskill
Carthage College Carthage College vs Guilford College Guilford College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Lenoir-Rhyne University Lenoir-Rhyne University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Pacific Lutheran University Pacific Lutheran University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Carroll University Carroll University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Concordia University-Wisconsin Concordia University-Wisconsin
Carthage College Carthage College vs Edgewood College Edgewood College
Carthage College Carthage College vs Lakeland University Lakeland University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Maranatha Baptist University Maranatha Baptist University
Carthage College Carthage College vs Marquette University Marquette University
Carthage College Carthage College vs University of Wisconsin-Whitewater University of Wisconsin-Whitewater
Carthage College Carthage College vs Herzing University-Kenosha Herzing University-Kenosha